Home schooled children "accomplish more academically than in traditional schools. Home schooling uses pedagogical approaches other than those typical in institutional schools, and enhance family relationships between children and parents and among siblings" (Ray, 2016)
Is home schooling giving our children certain advantage over traditional schooling system? (Ray, 2016)
Parents of all faiths and walks of life have adopted to school their children at home due to the inherent benefits to children such an approach offers.
There is an estimated 2% to 8% annual increase of home schooled children with an estimated amount of 2.3 million presently in such ranks.
Home schooled children perform better than the average student in the social, emotional and psychological arena. Including peer interaction, self-concept, self-esteem, and other leadership skills.
Here are some facts,
"General Facts, Statistics, and Trends"
- Homeschooling – that is, parent-led home-based education; home education – is an age-old traditional educational practice that a decade ago appeared to be cutting-edge and “alternative” but is now bordering on “mainstream” in the United States. It may be the fastest-growing form of education in the United States. Home-based education has also been growing around the world in many other nations (e.g., Australia, Canada, France, Hungary, Japan, Kenya, Russia, Mexico, South Korea, Thailand, and the United Kingdom).
- A demographically wide variety of people homeschool – these are atheists, Christians, and Mormons; conservatives, libertarians, and liberals; low-, middle-, and high-income families; black, Hispanic, and white; parents with Ph.D.s, GEDs, and no high-school diplomas. One study shows that 32 percent of homeschool students are Black, Asian, Hispanic, and others (i.e., not White/non-Hispanic) (Noel, Stark, & Redford, 2013).
Quote taken from: "Research Facts on Homeschoolilng". (Ray, 2016).
- There are about 2.3 million home-educated students in the United States. This is up from one estimate that there were about 2 million children (in grades K to 12) home educated during the spring of 2010 in the United States (Ray, 2011). It appears the homeschool population is continuing to grow (at an estimated 2% to 8% per annum over the past few years).
https://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html
Are home schooled students- children or adults better trained and better prepared in terms of quality, quantity and facts?
Can your home-schooled children obtain a Masters or even a Ph.D or tenure at a university if they were home-schooled? or if they obtain a Distance Learning masters or doctoral degree from an accredited university?
The
relatively low prices for personal computers, the invention of the Internet and
the proliferation of the World Wide Web has brought significant amount of
changes in the way people learn (Forcier, 1999).
In the
1800’s people earned a living my means of agriculture. In the 1900’s most
people lived in industrial societies (FitzGerald & Dennis, 1999).
The 20th
century, on the other hand, has become associated with information,
communications and instant messages across the world. Rightly so, it has taken
the name of “information age”. Individual, scholastic, and commercial success
depend, almost exclusively, on information technology and communications
intelligence and this is especially true since the advent of the Internet and
the World Wide Web (FitzGerald & Dennis, 1999).
In the
early years of the 20th century and before then, it took many days,
weeks, months, even years for data, information, or letters to be conveyed from
one point to another. Today, it only takes a matter of seconds before data
reaches another person across the globe or even across our solar system.
FitzGerald & Dennis (1999) said we have learned to collapse the information
lag.
Legitimate distance learning Degrees
The National Center for
Educational Statistics projected the total number of doctoral awards to go from
45,200 in 1998 to a figure of 49,500 by the year 2008. (NCES Projections2, 1998).
Although the number of doctoral degrees has increased for the
past 13 years, we do not know how many of those degrees have been issued by DL
programs and DL institutions which grant those degrees (Lewis, 2002).
There appears to be very little
literature (although this is rapidly changing) regarding the subject of
distance learning and skepticism is expressed on the part of some academic
personnel of traditional universities regarding the value of distance learning
Ph.D. degrees.
Nevertheless, issuing graduate degrees
has become a growing market for many traditional and non-traditional
universities. Masters, and Doctoral degrees, once termed, “scorned” are now
being looked at with more respect and acceptance and even offered by Ivy League
schools (Forelle, 2002).
Although there have been a number of
studies showing the DL learning degrees for graduate work and undergraduate
work are just as valuable to employers and employees, there continues to remain
an aura of disbelief, distrust and skepticism towards those graduates who earn
such degrees (West 1995). The same amount of skepticism is shown towards
institutions that issue DL learning Ph.D. degrees (Koredoski, 2001).
For instance, Lewis (2002), Vice
Provost and Dean for the School of Graduate Studies for the University of
Michigan, stated that some DL graduate programs are effective as long as the
training and education is provided in conjunction with practical laboratory and
industry experience. Although the statement was specifically applied to liberal
studies, Lewis indicated that engineering and M.B.A masters programs could also
be successful if they were offered in conjunction with practical industry and
laboratory experience (Forelle, 2002).
Competencies differences between DL and traditional graduates
While DL
has helped thousands of people today, it has also created challenges, like the
ability or inability to cope with feeling of isolation and lack of
collaboration as students learn from far away places and distance learning
institutions.
Nevertheless,
the question posed by many is: “are DL degrees as or more valuable to employees
and employers than traditional degrees?”(Koredoski, 2001). If so, have they
successfully produced quality graduates?
Timura
(1995) answered that question when he originally suggested that DL learning
degrees produce better educational results than otherwise traditional
education.
West (1995)
said many authors found little difference in the acceptability and
negotiability between traditional and DL or non-traditional degree holders.
Challenges ahead
According to
Oblinger, Barone & Hawkins (2001) the next few years will require deep
educational reforms in order to ensure that everyone who participates in
learning is provided with the best of the practice. This is especially true of
future Ph.D. graduates.
The digital methodologies adopted by many traditional learning and other teaching institutions will need to be modified in order to adjust to new educational methods and formats of delivery. Again, this applies equally well to doctoral degrees (Lewis, 2002).
The digital methodologies adopted by many traditional learning and other teaching institutions will need to be modified in order to adjust to new educational methods and formats of delivery. Again, this applies equally well to doctoral degrees (Lewis, 2002).
Thus while
Timura suggested that DL learning degrees produce better educational results
than traditional education., will a doctoral degree obtained via DL methods be
equally classified as educationally better?
Since
doctoral graduates are needed to teach at all levels of learning, will a holder
of a DL doctoral degree, in any discipline, obtain professorship and tenure
status in the traditional universities of today?
Studies continue to indicate that millions
of motivated students are continuing their education via Distance Learning (DL)
methods, of all the way up to the Ph.D. level, even though there is a great
deal conflict regarding the value of DL undergraduate, graduate and doctoral
degrees (Koredoski, 2001 and West, 1995).
Is there value in distance learning Ph.D. programs?
Many are beginning to accept the fact
that DL methodologies are producing new sets of learners, paradigms, and
institutions (Schneider, 1999).
Distance Learning, as a new learning method has become one of the most complex issues that face modern day higher educators and education in general. Therefore, Distance learning (DL) is beginning to give way to more accurate terms like distributed learning.
Distance Learning, as a new learning method has become one of the most complex issues that face modern day higher educators and education in general. Therefore, Distance learning (DL) is beginning to give way to more accurate terms like distributed learning.
That is why Oblinger, Barone &
Hawkins (2001) use the terminology “distributed learning” when speaking of
distance learning since DL, otherwise would be a highly restrictive and
inaccurate term, they said.
But why the Reluctance one may ask?
Why, then are some Deans of
traditional universities appear to be reluctant to use these DL new paradigms
of teaching, especially those that affect graduate and Ph.D. doctoral programs?
(Lewis, 2002).
Many who have had one on-one
experience with DL doctoral graduates openly accept the legitimacy and qualifications
of such degrees. However, the difference between their open acceptance and an
open rejection appears to be in their perception of DL and distributed learning
(DL) technologies (Koredoski, 2001). And perception is sometimes taken as
truth.
Peat and Helland (2003) defined
perception as reality since people generally select as true any information
that supports their hypothesis. Therefore, if an academic employer, tenured
professors, or the Dean of a university perceives that an DL doctoral degree is
not comparable in quality to their own degree as obtained from a traditional
brick and mortar university, then for him or her, that perception is “true”.
Such perception becomes instantly detrimental to a doctoral graduate applying for professorship in their institution (Fishbein & Ajzen 1975).
Such perception becomes instantly detrimental to a doctoral graduate applying for professorship in their institution (Fishbein & Ajzen 1975).
Other reasons for Reluctance:
Elitism is
one of the reasons some traditionally trained professors refuse to accept DL
doctoral degrees.
The
majority of professors who hold tenure and faculty positions in traditional
universities argue they went, for years, through a great deal of work in order
to graduate from doctoral brick and mortar universities. Therefore, many of
these same professors prefer to have colleagues who, likewise, “paid their
dues” and earned their Ph.D. degrees from traditional “brick and mortar”
universities. “It comes down to paying your dues”, said Mr. Fant, a traditional
Ph.D. graduate from Union University in Tennessee (Montell,
2003).
The
Legitimacy of DL advanced degrees- And
Legitimate
universities around the world granting Distance Learning Ph.D. Degrees
One of the
largest universities in Europe, England- the Open
University, enrolls more than 110,000 undergraduate students, and over 30,000
graduate students via distance learning.
The Open
University degrees are based entirely on distance studies. Many of the part
time and full time faculty of the Open University obtained their graduate and
doctoral degrees from DL universities (Donovan, Scanlon & Whitelegg, 2000).
Other examples
abound of legitimately and regionally accredited universities in the USA and abroad
who offer advanced degrees up to the doctoral level (Author, 2005).
Nova
Southeastern, Capella University, in the USA, UNISA in South
Africa, are among some of them.
Brown University in Boston, MA is presently
part of 52 universities who form part of the International Virtual Medical School, (IVIMEDS).
This program will bring medical education via blends of e-learning (Distance Learning)
and face-to-face methods to train doctors for countries in Africa and others
all the way from undergraduate to post graduate studies (Forelle, 2002 &
IVMEDS, 2003).
The Expected
abilities described by Brown Medical School in Boston, the Six competencies
by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education in the USA, and seven
outcomes by the International Institute for Medical Education, provide IVIMEDS program
the legitimacy accorded and expected from any traditional medical school.
Kuskis
(2003) said there is a crucial need for better and newer vision for globally
affected Distance Learning technologies. Changes need to originate at the
institutional level so that all affected institutions contract the best of
faculty and instructional designers. This includes the selection from a global
pool rather than just the traditionally and locally selected tenured faculty.
While it
may seem easier to manage traditionally selected and local faculty, their
teaching methodologies are not necessarily better. Some of the globally
selected faculty, whom may be better equipped to teach, inevitably may one day
come from those who hold distance learning Ph.D. degrees from fully accredited
universities (Kuskis, 2003).
Management
and Business View of Ph.D. degrees
Many DL doctoral
graduates have successfully attained positions and their ultimate goals in
industry or in the commercial world. However, it is not known if the same
amount of success applies to doctoral graduates seeking academic or teaching
jobs (Montell, 2003).
Hiring
managers and tenured professionals and academia have already learned to discern
that DL higher education including masters and doctoral degrees is
significantly knowledge-based and, besides the mandatory course work, it makes
practical use of one’s past experience (West, 1995). This is precisely what DL
affords a new set of learners all over the world in this information age.
Summary
Scholar
Albert Cheng stated: "Students who are home schooled may
attain a greater degree of self-actualization because homeschooling
is highly conducive to personalized instruction and enables students
to be taught a consistent worldview".
Cheng stated further: "Second, the religious values taught in a homeschooling environment as well as in many religious private schools are consistent with political tolerance and other values necessary for a liberal democracy".
https://www.nheri.org/home-school-researcher/volume-29-issue-4/a-brief-review-of-does-homeschooling-or-private-schooling-promote-political-intolerance-evidence-from-a-christian-university-by-albert-cheng.html
According to the national center for education statistics, 36% of homeschooling families were primarily motivated by a desire to provide religious or moral instruction.
Another 38% said the primary reason they homeschool is because they don’t like the school environment or the way teachers teach—those numbers are also way up from a few years ago.
Since
young students today subjected to an enforced secularism and
God-lessness throughout the entire educational system, some parents
adopt not to accept such form of education for their children.
Some
parents have discovered that traditional schools are not producing
the results that parents want out of their educational goals for
their children.
Thus,
with all the literature showing that homeschooling is giving our
children much advantage during their forming years, parents are
opting for this path that may ultimately lead their children to fully
formed professionals that will have been influenced little or not at
all by some of the traditional brick and mortar schools and universities that
are a shadow of what they once were.
The level of sophistication of
today’s teaching methods have reached proportions that permit some institutions
to grant advanced distance learning (DL) including doctoral degrees with a
great deal of success.
Recommendations
An increasing number of learning
institutions are successfully educating and accredited graduates all the way to doctoral level from
all disciplines which are of equal or better quality than those issued by
traditional learning universities. This article has attempted to inform its
readers of the value, perception, and potential of challenges for present home-school and perhaps future doctoral
graduates of accredited Learning institutions.
It is especially geared to those who wish to pursue any career at any learning institution (Donovan, Scanlon & Whitelegg, 2000). Including for the home-schooled children of today.
Ackerman,
E., & Hartman, K. (2001). Information Searcher's Guide to Searching and
Researching on the Internet and W3 (2nd Ed.) Wilsonville,
Oregon: Franklin Beedle & Associates,
Inc.
Anckar,
B., & D'Incau, D. (2002). Value-Added Services in Mobile
Commerce: An Analytical Framework and Empirical Findings from a National
Consumer Survey. In IEEE (Vol. 3, p. 86b). 35th Annual Hawaii
International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS'02).
Belanger,
F., & Jordan, D. (2000). Evaluation and Implementation of Distance
Learning: Technologies and Techniques. London,
UK: Idea Group
Publishing.
Donovan,
C., Hodgson, B., Scanlon, E., & Whitelegg, E. (2000, May). ALIS:
Associate Lecturers in Science [Special issue]. Retrieved February 3, 2004, from The Open
University: http://www.openuniversity.edu
Fishbein,
M., & Ajzen, I. (1975). Beliefs, Attitude,
Intention, and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research. Reading,
Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley.
FitzGerald,
J., & Dennis, A. (1999). Business Data Communications and Networking
(6th Ed.) New York, New York:
John Wiley & Sons. (Original work published 1998)
Forcier,
R. C. (1999). The Computer as an Educational Tool (2nd Ed.) Upper
Saddle River,
N.J: Prentice Hall.
Forelle,
C. (2002, January 23). Ivey League Schools to Offer Online Courses. Wall
Street Journal.
Hazemi,
R., Hailes, S., & Wilbur, S. (1999). Collaborative Interactions in Support
of Learning: Models, Metaphors and Management. In The Digital
University (p. 40). London,
England: Springer
-Verlag. (Original work published 1998)
Jackson,
S. A., Ph.D. (2004). Ahead of the Curve: Future Shifts in Higher Education. EDUCAUSE,
January/February (2004).
James,
S. D. (2001). Introduction to the Internet (3rd Ed.) Upper
Saddle River, N.J.: Prentice
Hall, Inc.
Koredoski,
A. E., PhD. (2001). The Value of Distance Learning MBA Programs to Employees
and Employers. Dissertation: UMI Number, Nova Southeastern University.
Lewis,
E. (2002). The Prospective Outlook for Graduate Education: The Opportunity
To Plan. Paper presented at the Midwestern Association of Graduate Schools
2002 Meeting. Retrieved March 6, 2004,
from
http://associations.smsu.edu/mags/2000mags/prospective_look_for_graduate_ed.htm
Montell,
G. (2003, August 6). Battling the Stigma of Nontraditional Credentials. The
Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved March 3, 2004, from The Chronicle.com:
http://chronicle.com/jobs/2003/08/2003080601c.htm
NCES
Projections2. (1998). Projections of Education Statistics to 2008. NCES,
Tables 29 and 30. Retrieved March
19, 2004, from NCES: hppt://nces.ed.gov/pubs98/pj2008/p98t29.html
Oblinger,
D. G., Barone, C. A., & Hawkins, B. L. (2001). Distributed Education and
its Challenges: An Overview. American Council on Education.
Oblinger,
D. G., Barone, C. A., & Hawkins, B. L. (2001). Distributed Education and
Its Challenges: An Overview. American Council on Education/EDUCAUSE.
Peat,
J., & Helland, K... Perceptions of Distance Learning and the Effects on
Selection Decisions -Retrieved March
1, 2004, from http://?
Schneider,
A. (1999). Masters Degree's: Once Scorned, Attract Students and Generate
Revenues. Retrieved May 1, 2004,
from Chronicle of Higher Education:
http://chronicle.com/colloquy/newsmaster/background/html
Schneiderman,
A. R., PhD. (1996). Librarians and the Net: Why Librarians Should Rule the Net?
ENode, 1(4).
Subcommittee
for New and Revised Programs,, F. (1997, April). Rackham Executive Board
Document # 97-98/5. University of
Michigan.
Timura, M. (1995). Perceptions of Human Resource Administrators Regarding Decisions to Support Distance Learning Activities for Employees. University of Connecticut. UMI Order Number 9539529.
West,
J. (1995). A Comparative Analysis of Selected on-campus and External Graduate Engineering
Degree Programs. Lehigh University.
Dissertation UMI order number 9519847. UMI Order Number 9519847.
"Why homeschooling is better than traditional school" http://www.worldofmoms.com/articles/why-home-schooling-is-better-than-traditional-schooling/666/4
Research Facts on Homeschooling. (Ray, 2016. Obtained July 2017).https://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html
Parts of this essay were printed and published on
Research Facts on Homeschooling. (Ray, 2016. Obtained July 2017).https://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html
Copyright Computer Integrations, Inc. ©, 2017
Fred Echeverria,
MSc. Computer Science
Ph.D. (abd) Computer Science
Fred Echeverria,
MSc. Computer Science
Ph.D. (abd) Computer Science
No part of this article may be reproduced or copied without
the author’s exclusive permission
Last Updated Wednesday, July 12, 2017
No part of this article may be reproduced or copied without
the author’s exclusive permission.
Parts of this essay were printed and published on
Thursday, November 17, 2005
Last Updated Wednesday, July 12, 2017